
There are all sorts of aircraft out there for basic flight training. A new model (or in some cases an entirely new design) seems to come out every other year! The more famous manufacturers include Cessna, Piper and Cirrus (at least on the American side). Other countries are developing and flying trainers as well but the American models are still the most popular worldwide.
I started my Private training in the Piper Warrior II – the Cherokee - back in 2005. It was a dated bird (a model built back in the early 80s) but a sturdy and well kept one! To date, my smoothest landing was in that model! It was a greaser! Moreover, I currently have over 80 hours total flight time (I am still a novice in aviation terms!).
I started flying the Cessnas earlier this year. I have flown the 172SP (the latest design in Cessna’s relentless pursuit of Skyhawk perfection) and the Cessna 172N (a 1977 model with that bothersome carburetor heat valve!).
I was flying out over a training area in the 172SP back in February with an instructor, listening to the radio exchange between the other pilots in the area. There were about six other airplanes maneuvering out there in different pockets (crowded airspace)! You can learn a lot about different types of training aircraft by just listening to the chatter! I learned early on that there were Cirrus, a Piper Seminole, a Piper Cherokee and another Cessna 172 in my immediate airspace.
The exchange between the flight instructors of the Cherokee and the Cessna, which seemed friendly at first, got progressively testy as they argued over which training aircraft was better, or more student-user friendly. Cooler heads prevailed only after some chiding from the pilots of the Cirrus and the Seminole. The Seminole pilot even jokingly (though I was not fully convinced) suggested that he would report the incident to the tower on the way in if he could get their tail numbers!
That incident (though irresponsible on the part of the instructors involved because their respective students lost valuable flight time – and money – as a result) gave me cause for reflection. I could compare both models quite easily because of personal experience.
I can say that I liked the Piper for its handling characteristics on the ground and its tendency to forgive less than perfect landings (my instructor at that time was not a real asset to me in terms of my landing training). My only serious gripe with the airplane involved the fuel tank configuration. I kept an alarm stopwatch handy to remind me not to run my tanks dry.
I like the Cessna 172 for its over-the-dashboard visibility and the great visibility of the landscape from the air. Landing was always a challenge (there are very few instructors who can truly teach you how to land a Skyhawk!).
I know that the opinions about Pilots who have flown both models would vary, but I think I have covered the most popular ones!